By Marc Apple ● ● 8 min read
Table of Contents
T::DR Client reviews are the most powerful, underutilized tool for improving a law firm’s local SEO, building trust, and generating new client inquiries through consistent, ethical outreach.
No time to read? Listen to a conversation about this blog post instead.
If you’re trying to grow your law firm’s visibility online, there’s one overlooked asset that delivers both immediate trust and long-term search engine dominance: client reviews.
Too often, attorneys think reviews are just nice extras. But in truth, they are one of the strongest local SEO ranking signals—and your competitors know it.
Too often, attorneys think reviews are just nice extras
The Real SEO Value of Reviews for Law Firms
Online reviews are more than just digital word-of-mouth. They influence three critical aspects of your marketing:
- Search Visibility: Google values authentic, consistent reviews—especially when tied to your Google Business Profile. Review volume and frequency are core components in ranking your firm in the Local Pack.
- Consumer Trust: Potential clients see reviews as social proof. Positive feedback acts as a third-party endorsement, often more persuasive than your own website copy.
- Conversion Rates: According to a study by Lawmatics, nearly 80% of legal consumers say that reviews on Google influence their decision to contact a law firm. A well-maintained review profile increases the likelihood of form fills, calls, and consultation requests by building trust and demonstrating consistent performance.
Imagine this: A mid-sized personal injury firm implements a review request workflow in their CRM and gathers 30 new five-star reviews over two months. Their local map visibility improves, and potential clients now see detailed, fresh feedback when searching. Even without formal attribution software, the firm notices a measurable uptick in calls and inquiries—especially those mentioning “great reviews” as the reason for reaching out.
While anecdotal, scenarios like this are becoming increasingly common. As review profiles grow, firms tend to see more engagement and conversions, making review generation a direct contributor to lead growth.
Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trust are essential for law firm SEO
E-E-A-T: How Reviews Signal Quality to Google and Prospects
Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trust (E-E-A-T) are essential for law firm SEO:
- Experience: Reviews describing real interactions highlight your firm’s hands-on impact.
- Expertise: Clients often cite legal knowledge or courtroom skill, reinforcing your credibility.
- Authoritativeness: A well-reviewed firm appears as a local leader in its practice area.
- Trust: Timely responses and acknowledgment of feedback, both positive and negative, build confidence.
Why Review Automation Doesn’t Cut It in Legal
Automated review requests work for e-commerce but fall flat in legal. With a small pool of cases each month, law firms can’t rely on the same tactics used by businesses processing thousands of transactions.
Tools that send batch emails may yield a few reviews, but they miss the personal connection. Law is built on relationships, and your review collection efforts should reflect that.
Review Collection Funnel: A Visual Process
| Stage | Action |
|---|---|
| Client Milestone | Case closed, consult completed, or legal service delivered |
| Trigger Review Request | CRM flags status and creates task or sends review invite |
| Personal Follow-Up | Staff member calls or texts within 24–48 hours |
| Send Review Link | Direct link provided for quick access to review platforms |
| Monitor Response | Follow up respectfully if no review is received after a few days |
| Track Results | Log review status to measure success and improve outreach strategy |
To make your review strategy actionable, think of it as a funnel:
- Client Milestone: Case closed, consultation completed, or service delivered.
- Trigger Review Request: Use your CRM to flag this milestone and generate a task or auto-send a request.
- Personal Follow-Up: A staff member follows up via text or phone within 24–48 hours.
- Send Review Link: Make it easy to leave a review by providing a direct link.
- Monitor Response: If no review is left, follow up politely after a few days.
- Track Results: Log whether a review was received and where, helping refine your outreach approach.
This simple funnel ensures consistency without compromising personalization—making your review strategy scalable.
People are more likely to respond to a personal request than a generic email
5 Practical Ways to Build a Strong Review Portfolio
1. Personal Outreach to Former Clients
Nothing beats a one-on-one follow-up. Call or text clients you’ve served well. Make the ask directly and be ready to send the review link immediately. People are more likely to respond to a personal request than a generic email.
Success varies by practice area. For example, personal injury clients—especially those who win compensation—are often enthusiastic about leaving positive reviews. In contrast, areas like family law may present more challenges due to the sensitive and emotional nature of the cases. In these situations, patience and discretion are key when requesting feedback.
2. Encourage Professional Character References
It’s perfectly acceptable to have peers, referral partners, or colleagues leave a character-based review. These testimonials can highlight your professionalism, integrity, and service ethos—crucial for potential clients evaluating your firm.
3. Post-Case Reviews from Satisfied Clients
When a case closes on a high note, follow up within a few days. The experience is still fresh, and satisfied clients are more likely to share their story.
4. Ask After Consultations—Even Without Retention
Did you provide clarity during a free consultation? That value matters. It’s okay to ask for a review even if the prospect didn’t hire you. Focus on the help you provided, not just the outcome.
5. Team-Based Review Initiatives
For larger firms, involve the whole team. Create simple contests or reward systems for staff who collect reviews. Intake specialists, paralegals, and junior attorneys often have deep rapport with clients—and their engagement can lead to more reviews.
How Many Reviews Do You Really Need?
| Month | Clients Contacted | Reviews Requested | Reviews Received | Response Rate (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 20 | 15 | 5 | 33% |
| Feb | 25 | 20 | 6 | 30% |
| Mar | 30 | 25 | 8 | 32% |
| Apr | 28 | 22 | 7 | 32% |
Use a basic log like this to track your outreach efforts. Over time, these metrics help you set realistic monthly benchmarks and improve your follow-up strategies.
There’s no one-size-fits-all number. Instead of chasing a magic review count, focus on creating a sustainable, repeatable system for collecting them.
High-performing firms often gather reviews weekly or monthly, depending on their client volume. Set your own internal benchmarks:
- Track how many clients or consultations you handle each month
- Measure how many of those result in a review when asked personally
- Use that baseline to set realistic monthly goals
What matters most is consistency and recency. A steady stream of current reviews signals that your firm is active and trusted—not stagnant. This matters as much to Google as it does to potential clients.
Don’t limit your efforts to Google alone
Beyond Google: Reviews Across Key Legal Platforms
| Platform | Visibility Level | Trust with Legal Consumers | Lead Generation Potential | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| High | Very High | High | Primary review destination; most visible | |
| Avvo | Medium | High | Medium | Legal-specific; great for attorney credibility |
| Justia | Medium | Moderate | Medium | Useful for SEO; supports detailed practice info |
| Yelp | Medium | Moderate | Variable | More relevant in urban areas |
| Low | Moderate | Low to Medium | Easy for casual reviews; not legal-specific |
While Google remains the most visible and impactful review platform—often being the first place potential clients look—supplementing it with other channels helps round out your reputation. Diversifying also ensures you’re discoverable wherever legal consumers are researching.
Don’t limit your efforts to Google alone. Legal-specific platforms like Avvo, Justia, and Martindale-Hubbell also influence your online reputation and visibility. Each has its own guidelines for reviews, and prospective clients often visit multiple directories before making contact.
Optimize your presence across:
- Avvo: Encourage clients to leave detailed feedback and complete the practice area-specific questions.
- Justia: Ensure your profile is claimed and accurate, then prompt happy clients to share their experiences.
- Yelp: Especially in larger cities, Yelp plays a surprisingly influential role in legal discovery.
- Facebook: Recommendations on your business page can improve brand perception and are easy to collect.
Making Reviews Work Harder: Repurpose and Reuse
Repurposing reviews as content—like those used in blog posts or videos—can support your broader content marketing strategy.
Every great review is a mini-testimonial. Here’s how to reuse them:
- On your website (with schema markup for SEO)
- In social media posts (as quote graphics or video overlays)
- Inside email campaigns (e.g., a client spotlight or case study)
- For local ads (including PPC landing pages)
Law firms must ensure compliance with local bar and ABA guidelines
Ethical Considerations for Review Solicitation
To ensure your firm follows best practices, it’s essential to align your review efforts with Google’s review policies. These guidelines prohibit fake content, incentivized reviews, and reviews that contain confidential or personal information.
Understanding the ethical boundaries around legal marketing, including review solicitation, is essential to staying compliant.
Law firms must ensure compliance with local bar and ABA guidelines:
- Never offer compensation for a review.
- Disclose relationships in character reviews.
- Don’t ask for reviews that could compromise client confidentiality.
Review Tools for Law Firms: Pros & Cons
Many firms benefit from tools designed specifically for legal marketing, helping streamline outreach and performance tracking.
While automation isn’t ideal for requests, tools can still help manage your review strategy:
Podium: Best for centralized text review invites.
Grade.us: Good for tracking and multi-platform management.
GatherUp: Ideal for multi-location firms with reporting needs.
All tools should be used for monitoring and strategic follow-up—not as a replacement for personal interaction.
Your law firm’s reputation is already being formed online
Make Reviews Easy with Workflow Integration
Many top-performing law firms use their CRM or case management system to integrate review requests directly into their client offboarding process. This can be as simple as a follow-up email or text triggered by a status change (e.g., case closed), or a task reminder prompting staff to reach out personally.
Using automated prompts inside the CRM ensures consistency while preserving a personal touch. It also helps track who was asked, when, and the outcome—allowing you to optimize your strategy over time.
Reviews Are a Priority, Not an Afterthought
Your law firm’s reputation is already being formed online. The question is whether you’re shaping it or leaving it to chance. Reviews help control your narrative while boosting your SEO performance.
Get a Free Law Firm Review Strategy Evaluation
If you’d like personalized guidance on how to improve your law firm’s review acquisition process, including platform targeting, outreach strategies, and workflow integration, my team and I can help. Click here to schedule your free Lead Flow Acceleration Session and learn how to build a review portfolio that drives visibility, credibility, and client inquiries.
FAQ About Reviews For Law Firms
Can character reviews help my law firm’s SEO?
Yes. As long as they’re genuine and posted by real people who know your professional qualities, they support your online reputation and are within Google’s guidelines.
Is it okay to ask for reviews more than once?
Absolutely. Just space out your follow-ups and stay courteous. Persistence often pays off.
Should I respond to reviews?
Yes. Replying shows you’re engaged and value client feedback. It also helps with SEO.
What if I only handle a few cases a month?
Focus on maximizing reviews from every client interaction—even consultations. Quality over quantity still moves the needle.
How do reviews affect visibility in AI tools like ChatGPT?
AI platforms increasingly rely on aggregated sentiment and reputation signals. Strong reviews can influence how your firm is mentioned or recommended.
Can bad reviews hurt my SEO?
One or two won’t if you have a strong portfolio. Address negative feedback respectfully and use it to demonstrate your firm’s responsiveness.
Are review incentives allowed?
You can incentivize staff to ask for reviews, but not clients to leave them. Avoid violating platform rules by offering gifts in exchange for testimonials.
How often should I ask for reviews?
Consistently. Build it into your client offboarding or consultation follow-up process.
Are there ethical concerns when requesting reviews?
Yes. Avoid asking for reviews that reveal sensitive information or breach confidentiality. Follow state bar and ABA marketing rules.
What role do platforms like Avvo and Yelp play in reviews?
They provide additional visibility and credibility, especially when clients use multiple sources to vet legal service providers.
What tools can help manage reviews?
Platforms like Podium, Grade.us, and GatherUp help you centralize requests and track performance—just don’t rely on them exclusively for outreach.
